Puzzle...

if the B and C can't understand A then B is forced to be a Sith and then C a jedi, A can be the fuck he want , my solutions continue valid

Both the problem have double solution, but i have to say to the OP (@NovelSub ), fuck you and fuck LOGIC, if you want to make a problem of this type make that only one solution is valid

 

Nya that's my laughing style

 

No, there is often more than one answer. X^2=4
Plus it's suppossed to be a children game.

 

But only one solution is valid.

 

I agree with this

 

Thats wrong because A could say "I am a jedi" and actually be lying.
Then B says "he said he is sith" and he lies as well.

 

just to test your knowledge
X^4=1
and
some real Logic - find the value of 5
1=6
2=5
3=9
4=8
5=?

 

The Sith can lie about lieing when the truth hurts more rendering the discussion mute.

 

We have two separate problems.

(a) Two possiblities:

1. Suppose A is a Jedi (always tells the truth) then his statement must be true. This is only possible if B is a Jedi (because A is not a Sith by assumption). Thus, A and B are both Jedi.

2. Suppose A is a Sith, then his statement must be false. If his statement is false then there are two possibilities: i) A is a Sith and B is a Jedi, ii) A is a Jedi and B is a Sith. Due to our assumption that A is a Sith only (i) is possible.

(b)

First, it is impossible for anyone to call themselves a Sith. A Sith that calls themself a Sith is telling the true and a Jedi the calls themself a Sith is telling a lie. Neither of these is possible, thus B is a Sith since A couldn't have said what B said A said.

Since, B is a Sith, C is telling the truth and is thus a Jedi.

We cannot determine what A is.

1) A could have lied (Sith), for example: "I am an invisible unicorn.". Both B and C's statements work out.
2) A could have told the truth (Jedi), for example "I am a Jedi." Both B and C's statements work out.

 

5=12

 

false, B make a statment about A statment not about A himself

 

1 -1 i -i
5=12

 

fail

this one is correct

 

Which part?
-1
+4
-1
+4...?

 

SAY NO TO MATH!

 

2=5 also implies that 5=2

 

a)
A is a Jedi
B is indeterminate since he didn't speak.
b)
A is indeterminate.
B is a Sith
C is a Jedi

 

Ha. You got me, tought we do sequences or series, but the way it was named.... fail
Trap >_>

 

True, however your missing out the possibility that they are both sith's in the first example and assuming that A and B are the same people in both examples. Then them both being sith's is the only solution.

 

Headache =.=" why you have to be like this...
I get what you say. We need the real answers now OP