Recommendations The novel's extra vs Trash of the Count's Family

Personally I prefer TCF, cause no harem and lots of pet, the thing I don't really like about TNE is some of the character is kinda annoying.
IMO tho, but overall both are good enough..

 

TNE is better in my opinion.

 

The only thing similar between them is the fact that they are transported into novels. Going by your logic, Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint is the same as the two other novels. Reading them all is the best option (sadly ORV is moving sites and TCF + TNE are going to be invisible in a few days)

 

I recommend My Castle, My Castellan
Seriously though, it depends on what you are looking for:
Medieval setting(Trash) or Modern setting(Novel Extra)

 

I hate harem so I don't like the Novel's Extra. Please recommend something like Trash of the count's family.

 

I've read both and although they're both fun reads, The Novel's Extra is a bit too clumsy, for a lack of a better word, in regards to the drama. It feels really forced at times... like Character A wants to tell Character B a very important secret, but something will interrupt them at a crucial moment and they'll just forget about it until it's forcibly brought up at the most unfortunate time. Some people might enjoy that, I personally just found it irksome.

 

Both are the same.
They start off interesting then in the middle they start to turn into boring generic stuff..
The problem of these 2 novel is that the novel have too many asspulls and everything always goes so smoothly.
Everything is easy here and the MC will never experience hardship or defeat or even mildly difficult problems.
All the powers and whatnot always falls into their laps without any effort.
Or OP minnions that comes out of nowhere to worship the MC in case of ToCF.
Its like watching a game in super easy mode where every treasures and powerups is just there for the pickings.
Its boring.

 

TCF is way better than TNE. Better story,better characters, no confusing leveling system where half the chapter is bunch of useless stat list.
TNE MC is a piece of scum. I hate the MC in TNE.