Hmm...well there's nothing really much about carl actually. I mean he just there being estelle brother doing his duty as the next duke. As the future the story mostly about emel and estelle and castiello problem with imperial. Even in the end of story there's really nothing about ain. After carl being duke, the novel just said that ain stay in another mansion (not in the capital) Oh carl is married. Well actually the hint about his wife is already quite predictable when i read the book but i think you will suprised if you know who his wife is hahaha Oh there's a story about carl, ain and estelle do a family vacation after all the mess with imperial ended.
Yesss you right !! Haha. Later anne hair back to black so she wouldn't looked like ilyal anymore, and she was wise and smart person, so i think she is fit the role as a duchess. They become close when anne helped estelle whenever carl interupted estelle time with emel, anne threatened him and said if you always do that estelle will hate you. So in the end carl listened to anne and they somehow become close. if im not wrong they will have son later. With black hair and red eyes.
Soon ~ i already planned it since it's been quite a long time since i gave a spoiler about them. Im pretty busy before, but i had some time now. Yeah same i love them too!
Hai here's another spoiler about emel and estelle ~ Spoiler: First Date Hai so i want to clarify something, about their first kiss is actually when they had a first date. I wrote a wrong spoiler before, but i already fix the title. so enjoy ~ So after estelle changing her clothes and went to music room (where emel waited for her) she found out that carl was had a fight with emel, fortunately estelle come in the right time and save emel from carl. They go by the chariot, and went to the forest as estelle requested it. Estelle was enjoying the journey, in the way emel said to estelle that he was not a faithful escort knight, estelle replied that she know that. after that they rested near the stream to feed the horse. as emel take care of the horse estelle jumped from the chariot and approached the stream. looked at the stream that transparent and not to deep estelle quickly took off her shoes and her stocking. emel looked at that and shock and asked what is she doing. and than estelle said to emel to don't looked at her way as she put off her stocking. Estelle come into the stream as she lifted up her skirt and emel was swearing from behind as he saw that, but estelle ignored him. emel warned estelle no go to deep, but as estelle played with the water she going more further. as emel saw that he told estelle to come out. as estelle didn't listen to him emel said "I think i already told you that im not your kind escort anymore." estelle replied "Oh, i don't mind." Emel quickly went to the stream and catch estelle. estelle asked "what are you doing?" emel replied "I'm saving my fiance from a cold." emel put estelle on the chaise lounge and told her to wear her stocking before he wore it (he being sarcastic). but estelle stretched her legs and jokingly said "would you like to help me to wear it?" (her intention was just to tease emel.) but instead emel snatched away the stocking from estelle as he smiles coldly and said "I will be happy to do that. Fiancee." after that emel cleaned estelle feet and legs with his handkerchief, with politely. as emel folded estelle stocking he put her legs on his legs and looked at estelle bare feet emel lifted it up and kissed her feet (OMG!! ) estelle body was shrugged with a shock and emel smiled at estelle reaction. emel started put the stocking on her legs and his hand move inside estelle skirt as he put the stocking (so the stocking was the type of stocking that must fasten it with garter belt from inside the skirt or it would loose) estelle was stunned to see that emel hand was moved inside her skirt and her heart was beating fast. after the stocking attached to the garter belt emel pull out his hand and asked "would you want me to help you to wear the stocking for other side too?" as he teased estelle. but estelle told emel to go and wear it herself and cursed him inside her mind and said that emel was a bad guy After that they continued the journey they had a silent moment for a moment and emel asked estelle if she acts like this in front of other men too. estelle was lost in thought and intentionally asked him (i think she want hurt emel here) will she become excited if she asked the same things to other men. emel expression becomes cold and asked "so you asked me just for comparison? are you going to ask someone else?" emel stopped the chariot and asked again "more than that i more curious about other things. what have you done with other men?" estelle replied "I have no obligation to talk." - "estelle" emel called her name for the first time as he leaned toward estelle. he said "Tell me." - "No." estelle refuse it. and then emel whispered in a low soft voice "I will kiss you if you don't speak." - "Try it or not." estelle replied. then emel kissed estelle lightly, they kissed as they looked at each other. after that emel said "If you compare this too, please let me know." actually estelle was a bit happy but then she yelled and asked emel what is he doing and emel said he just kissed his fiancee. they had an argument about that and they fell from the chariot. estelle asked emel again why he kissed her. emel said he was jealous. estelle told him that from the start they relationship just a contract so no matter she did or do with other men it was her business. emel said sorry and wont do that again with a gloomy face. in this situation estelle was really want to hurt emel and said "I can touch you but you can't touch me without my permission." - "Okay." After that they continue the journey and go home. in the way back estelle said "about the kissed." emel face hardened listened to it (he nervous about what estelle think) "Yes?". estelle laughed looked at his expression and said "I didn't hate it." haha it's quite long, but i hope you enjoyed it. i will post another later ~
Thank you so much for all of the spoilers! I love you! Ah, there's one thing I want to ask. Castiello's blood makes everyone (except their own children) afraid of them, right? So does this applies to their own spouse? I'm so glad Carl's later married but I don't want his wife be afraid of him I want both of them to be happy with each other! Lol. I'm rooting for Emiel x Estelle from the start but now I'm so excited to know more about Carl's married life
Well, that's true, even sometimes estelle think that Seo Yeon (her past life) memories didn't really help her to solve the problem, it just help her to know about the trend for the future. The memories about the past mostly help her when she was still live with her mother when she was a child. Due lack of education (her mother never really teach her to speak or read or anything) and mostly her time was locked in the box, so she was isolated from the world. if she never had her memories from the past she would grow up as an abnormal person (can't talk or understand anything), but she tried to learn some language, attitude, and other things from her memories and observing her mother. and thanks to her castiello blood she still survived even she was beaten very often. As i know she was mature enough that people around her said that she was too mature for her age and it was weird, even emel and roy said to her that sometimes they were more childish compared to her. Oh and there's a time when she was confused about her memories, she was too isolated when she was a child so she was thought maybe it was just a dream or it was a fantasy she made due to her poor life (she also think what if her other relative like uncle and her aunt she met was her imagination), she was noticed that when she met carl for the first time, she thought carl was just her imagination, but annie proved that there's her brother live in the mansion too (so she realized that the boy she met before/carl was real). as she happy live as estelle, the memories of her past life become more hazy and she doesn't really think about that either, but she still remember she was Seo Yeong before.
Hai ~ you're welcome Yes you right, but for Carl case because he will be married to Anne so it will be fine. Anne had castiello blood in her too (because she was being experimented by the wizard before). She doesn't afraid of him, when carl called her 'hey/you/wizard' she was talking back to carl and said that she have a name that estelle gave her, but carl ignored her at first and anne often talked sarcastically to carl. Finally when estelle married, and when anne crying alone, carl saw her and comfort her and said in his mind that she was not bad (they already pretty close at this time) i think it was first time for carl to thinking about any other women/girl beside estellle.
Thank you so much for taking the time to write spoilers! I’ve registered just so I can continue to read your updates, you’re very good at retelling the story. I hope you will be able to translate the novel into English for all the English fans out there! Even a summary would make us so happy to read.
aww you're welcome, i'm happy to share some spoiler too well actually i have thought about translate it tho, hopefully maybe next year, and i be happy to give some summary.
Here's another spoiler ~ Spoiler: Iris tea party So this is when Estelle meet Emel for the first time after Emel leave. At this time Estelle already become a Count (Count Solard/ one of the Castiello land that contamined and she secretly purified the land. In the end Ain know, and told estelle to take responsible to it.) so after emel leave, ain estelle and carl come back to the capital and start her debut in social circle. the first year she was there obviously the queen mama always invite estelle to her activity and she become a center of social circle, and irish was no where to be seen nor had invited to her mother activity, but suddenly iris invited estelle to palace and at that time iris already a different person she more confident more radiant and no more blind, she quite a nerve to estelle like she stole estelle dress design, she stole the idea of estelle salon, etc. after that estelle went to count solard for almost half a year to organized a thing there. after that she come back to the capital iris inivited her to tea party. And when estelle come she was acting friendly talk friendly but had an ill intention. and when they in conversation iris said she had someone she like and blushing (like a fox, uggh) and said she will introduce him later and want estelle to give her a compliment. and when Estelle asked who the person irish just said he is young marquis raymond. at that time estelle was had no idea who is he, because when emel was become a right successor estelle was in the count so she didn't heard about the news (apparently ain was sent her to count on purpose to hide the fact). after a while the servant called estelle that riddle called her, iris face become stiff. estelle excuse herself for a moment and meet riddle. after she come back to the tea party, the lady chattered about actually iris invited the marquis raymond too, and she need estelle and other lady support (ugh, i was sick of her) she beckoned the servant and told them to let the marquis come. after that estelle was very shock to know who is he, iris proudly stretch her hand, as emel come and kissed iris back hand. and irish teased estelle and said "Estelle he is my new marquis raymond". estelle was to shock, her hand was tremble and her body was like floating in the air, estelle broke the tea cup she hold and her hand was bleeding. Iris was had a happy face looked at estelle condition. and then estelle make an excuse to leave and iris gave her permission as she laughed as she winning someting. after that estelle know that everybody was know about emel except her. she was very mad at the betrayal she fired roy and yelled at ain in the office in front of everyone and said that she hated him (estelle never do that before), locked herself and run away to mac house (the pianist). Spoiler: Iris tea party 2 The revenge !! Estelle was run away in the midnight with her spirit End (the dragon) and arrived at mac balcony. he was suprised at her come but he let her in. in the end estelle told the reason why she was run away. she told the story and mac comfort her as he hugged her. but at that time mac was sick because estelle can felt the hot temperature. she take care of him and fall asleep. alpha move estelle to bed . in the morning mac was suprised found estelle laying beside him. estelle explain everything, after that she was hungry (when she locked herself for almost 3 days she didn't had anything to eat just a water from alpha.) and asked mac for the food. when the food was delivered the person who delivered it saw estelle and from that point the 'one bed rumor' had spread. estelle come back with mac, and short things out with ain and roy and they back to normal again. after that iris invited estelle to her tea party again (she want to humiliate estelle). but estelle had set her mind that she wont lose from iris and come to the tea party. And as always iris was played dumb when estelle come and told estelle that she had no idea that estelle didn't know emel was the marquis raymond. and estelle replied "ah don't tell me.", iris confused "yes?", estelle "i know you know it.", iris "yes?" , estelle "you know the fact but you hide it, right? it's okay." iris face become strange and estelle ignore it and sat down. iris "what are you talking about? you said i was lied?", estelle "yes." , iris "how can do you said that!" she was embarrased. as estelle pored the tea herself she said "Yes, you lied." and other lady was confused at they and at estelle who served her tea herself she doesn't care anymore she didn't want to become a social queen anyway. estelle asked iris "Isn't emel coming today?" , iris "estelle castiello! how come you be so rude. how can duke daughter become like this?", estelle replied "Yeah." as she cut the cake. estelle tasted it a bit and frowned estelle said again "iris i thought about it before, but i think you should use a different chef for the cake. the cookie was good but the cake are never good." as estelle said that the lady held their breath, estelle grinned at their reaction. Estelle put the fork, leaned back to the couch, crossed her legs and put out a finger and said "Don't you call emel?". iris exploded and shouted "Estelle Castiello! how can you be so rude. i thought we are friend. how can you insulting me in front of everyone?!" the ladies rose from their seat and looked at estelle appeasing a princess, everyone face was inevitable, but no one showed the hostility toward estelle. "If you don't called him, i will called him." estelle said that as she beckoning the servant to come closer to her. estelle told the servant to let in the guest inside the waiting room (emel). the servant was confused as he looked at iris, but in the end the servant decide to follow estelle order. as emel come in he was puzzled the strange atmosphere and he stopped midway. "Marquis Raymond, i apologize for my last rudeness. i didn't say hello before." estelle said that as she sit (it was rude way) and emel had a firm face. after a moment of silent estelle woke up and iris approached emel and hung at his arm "Marquis look! Castiello is a terrible woman now! she insult the marquis." after that emel calmed and said "I didn't said goodbye too before. forgive for my rudeness, lady." estelle "I'm not a lady anymore." estelle looked at emel that didn't change a bit, as she thought that she want to hurt him as much as he ruined her and as much as she cried. but not today. "Congratulation on your marquis." estelled greeted emel as she politely grab her skirt and added "and i hate you. so i hope i never see your face again." and then estelle looked at iris as iris looking at emel with a desperate face. then estelle said "Iris, i had a lot fun today. please inivite me next time. but i don't like sit next to you, so i want you to arrange another one. goodbye then." estelle leave and she can heard that iris screamed her name form afar. haha i was very satisfied with this part. serve everybody right.
Same! LOL! like he's too damn pathetic sometimes like dude, get over your shit be a knight, act your age! and I always love the brother! Daddy the bro are the best in this story!