I remember reading this novel during lockdown last year, but I sort of skipped around and didn't really finish it haha Here are some major spoilers I remember though. Spoiler: Main Villains The main/final villain of this novel is "Darkness", the representation of evil/chaos. His goal is to dominate the world, and he almost succeeded in the previous timeline, but the other transcendental beings (The Goddess, Black Dragon, and Black Magician) worked together to turn back time and thus, thwarted his plans. He is currently using Josephina, manipulating her into using violence against Leticia, and then framing her for all her misdeeds. He brainwashed the three real wings (Ahin, Callisto, and Kaylas) into serving Josephina as the real saint. Noelle wasn't brainwashed by Darkness, which was why she was able to immediately recognized Leticia as the real saint. He ends up getting destroyed by Julius (I think?) and then made to suffer for all of eternity by Sigmund, the Black Dragon. As for Josephina, she was actually a temporary saint appointed by the Goddess for a limited amount of time. However, Darkness took advantage of this and told her that he can help her be "real" and remain as the saint forever, so she forms a contract with him. All of her wings are fakes created by Darkness with the exception of the four (Ahin, Noelle, Callisto, and Kaylas) who are real wings, temporarily appointed by the Goddess. Unlike the real wings who devotes unconditional loyalty to the saint, the fakes/temporary wings' loyalty is much lower. Due to her incompetence, she loses all of the wings beside a couple of fake ones. This angered Darkness so she ends up being abandoned and killed by him in the end. Now if I remember correctly about Leticia's older half-brother, he was devoured by Darkness, so Darkness is currently using/playing him. That's why he never helped Leticia when she was being abused. I actually don't remember much about him to be honest. Spoiler: Julius Julius, Dietrian's older brother was actually one of the 9 wings. As a wing, he had the power of prophecy. He saw a future where everyone was happy, but for this to happen, he had to die. That's why he accepted his death and sacrificed himself for Dietrian's future happiness. Julius, with his power of prophecy, immediately knew the truth that Josephina was a false saint and thus was killed on the spot by her. While dying, he was laughing at Josephina (since he knew everyone would be happy except for her in the future), and this made Josephina despise him greatly. Later on in the story, he was resurrected and used as a puppet by Darkness.