Others who are here now, please vote even if you might change it before the day ends. I want to hear different opinions. As of now, only Tilg seems to have a confident case against Iso. decora voted solely based on the PR claim, so that vote doesn't sell me on it and I don't really trust Clumsy as of now even though there's nothing wrong per se that I can point out.
@iampsyx I think it was these three specifically. I'm getting something from this, just not quite sure what. I should have a clearer view of this if I get a few more data points/time from her, but as of now I'm not too inclined to call it either town or mafia ...it's probably a bit based on the fact I know soul quite well, though
I'm not done responding to posts yet, but I just wanna say that I don't think Isolated is wolf. My meta on his PR claim is one reason, and him voting Lissi is another. Wolves who've played with her before should think twice about targeting her (especially in the early stages of the game) if they don't want to be tunneled, no? So his sus on her seems to be coming from a genuine place.
Let me try writing down what I'm thinking for now , I'm pretty bad at organizing stuff like this and I just end up by confusing myself even more
DotA Mafia GameStatus: Day 1 - Waiting for votes. # Username ToD Role Warnings 1 @iampsyx --- --- 0 2 @Clumsy Soul --- --- 0 3 @Tilgarial --- --- 0 4 @SylviaViolet --- --- 0 5 @Grey_Angel --- --- 0 6 @Nagashiro --- --- 0 7 @Mr gentleman --- --- 0 8 @Glass Shard --- --- 0 9 @ReaderReader --- --- 0 10 @c.decora --- --- 0 11 @Devils Advocate --- --- 0 12 @Lissi --- --- 0 13 @Lemonfairy --- --- 0 14 @Isolated0371 --- --- 0 Votes TargetVoters (Posts in Phase) 3 Isolated0371 @Tilgarial (56), @c.decora (21), @Clumsy Soul (34) 2 Devils Advocate @Isolated0371 (40), @Lissi (49) 1 Mr gentleman @Devils Advocate (30) 1 Clumsy Soul @Nagashiro (40) 1 Nagashiro @SylviaViolet (15) 0 No Lynch --- 6 Not Voting @iampsyx (25), @Grey_Angel (9), @Mr gentleman (0), @Glass Shard (15), @ReaderReader (9), @Lemonfairy (30) Important Time Left
DotA Mafia GameStatus: Day 1 - Waiting for votes. # Username ToD Role Warnings 1 @iampsyx --- --- 0 2 @Clumsy Soul --- --- 0 3 @Tilgarial --- --- 0 4 @SylviaViolet --- --- 0 5 @Grey_Angel --- --- 0 6 @Nagashiro --- --- 0 7 @Mr gentleman --- --- 0 8 @Glass Shard --- --- 0 9 @ReaderReader --- --- 0 10 @c.decora --- --- 0 11 @Devils Advocate --- --- 0 12 @Lissi --- --- 0 13 @Lemonfairy --- --- 0 14 @Isolated0371 --- --- 0 Votes TargetVoters (Posts in Phase) 3 Isolated0371 @Tilgarial (56), @c.decora (21), @Clumsy Soul (34) 2 Devils Advocate @Isolated0371 (40), @Lissi (49) 1 Mr gentleman @Devils Advocate (30) 1 Clumsy Soul @Nagashiro (40) 1 Nagashiro @SylviaViolet (15) 0 No Lynch --- 6 Not Voting @iampsyx (25), @Grey_Angel (9), @Mr gentleman (0), @Glass Shard (15), @ReaderReader (10), @Lemonfairy (30) Important Time Left
I've never played mafia with Lissi before but from what I know about her I think you have a point. There must be a reason why he voted for Lissi
DotA Mafia GameStatus: Day 1 - Waiting for votes. Votes TargetVoters (Posts in Phase) 3 Isolated0371 @Tilgarial (56), @c.decora (21), @Clumsy Soul (35) 1 Lissi @Isolated0371 (41) 1 Mr gentleman @Devils Advocate (30) 1 Devils Advocate @Lissi (49) 1 Clumsy Soul @Nagashiro (40) 1 Nagashiro @SylviaViolet (15) 0 No Lynch --- 6 Not Voting @iampsyx (25), @Grey_Angel (11), @Mr gentleman (0), @Glass Shard (15), @ReaderReader (11), @Lemonfairy (30) Important You voted for Lissi. Time Left
it's a bit long but uh lemme dump this here, you can take it as my legacy post since I plan on just talking for the next 20 mins Spoiler: reads I think Psyx and Sylvia are both towny Psyx for townreading me so strongly- I honestly feel that if she was mafia, this wouldn't happen; my strongest impression of her as mafia (when I'm not her scumbuddy) was basically her being unreceptive to my posts and insisting that I was not towny- at the very least, I doubt she'd 'locktown' me I agree with Sylvia's posts on Iso, and I think that worrying about PRs is a really towny thought (I've kinda been thinking down the same lines, though there's more hesitance to believe it since it came so early) Lemon's initial posts were towny but I kinda wish she posted more, I don't think my read on her is as solid as the one on Psyx, despite me talking to Lemon directly more I think I'll need Iso's readlist to decide his alignment (sorry the request came close to EOD but yeah) I reread some meta and I think (?) I can draw a conclusion from it one way or another with the readlist, even if it won't be the most in-depth read ever DA's posts are kinda ??? still, I think his readlist was actually pretty towny but I also feel weird the posts after that (and Psyx hasn't said anything meta-wise)... would like an explanation but he's not here, I'll probably come back to him tomorrow if I'm still here Glass giving reads is a good sign Her gut reads came before reading the thread, which I found a little weird (I think the last thing I heard was from a year ago when she was using gut a lot, and she said that her gut usually only works once there's fewer people left- though I can't recall if she was mafia or town when she said that, sorry), but I think her elaboration on her reads later and continuing to make reads is towny Tilgarial I think is being his nice self which feels towny, but I feel like out of the reads I've noticed, they aren't really deep? Like, his read on Lemon was just an impression+my post+Psyx, and I'm not sure how I feel about that. He's also really insistent on me being wrong, which is kinda weird. Reader/Grey/Gentleman haven't posted enough AI stuff to make an impression on me, but I think Reader's been trying to contribute more than Grey and I think that his commentary on the votes is a good start VC says Clumsy/Nagashiro/Decora have a lot of posts but I can't remember any AI impression of those so uh... will examine tonight.