HS VS ATG: HS possibly better?

I am updated between two novels, and for someone who read ATG first, it seems that HS is a 2.0 improved version. For anyone who has read both novels, I was wondering which you think is better?



PS: Yes I know HS was first.

Edit: HS is Heavenly Star

 

what the birdshit is 'HS'?

 

what is hs? lol

 

Obviously, hs stands for high school!

 

HS?? whats that.

 

Is HS worth the read? I was wondering since I got bored of ATG after the whole repetitiveness fully kicked in.

 

Hyper sexual?

 

Thread tag does say "heavenly star"

 

its Heavenly star, its in the tag.
ye wuchen probably a bit better than ATG guy, tho the core is the same.

 

I haven't read HS yet, but i might now

 

HS stands for Heavenly Star
about which being better, I think that ATG seemed equally interesting at that chapter stage, though yeah the lack of complete info about the MC's past makes it a bit more intriguing, as in case of Spirit Realm

 

I like HS but theres something about ATG that makes me keep coming back . Update wise, ATG got a more stable one than HS so I usually stack chapters before reading HS

 

oh my fault then!

 

Idk what heavenly star is but atg is boring atm. It was the best novel at the first 200 chaps but then just becomes repetitive

 

I finished reading HS ( mtl) ...and I think ATG is way better... i didn't like the way HS ended

 

Heavenly Star supposedly came first, and the one guy I know who can actually read mandarin says that it's much better than ATG and that you can clearly see where mars has blatantly reused things from HS in ATG.

That said, ATG is ongoing so things might get better. Maybe.

 

I like HS better but I also liked ATG better in the beginning (that torture scene with the guy who poisoned him, OMG so great to read.). So since since HS is still at 100 chapters (that I can read at least) there's always the possibility that it will slowly devolve to the point where I view both of them as being of the same quality.

 

I feel HS is better than ATG. However Mars Gravity has a tendency to make his MCs too rapey. This makes me hate HS a bit too.

 

i dont think so , after all yun che relies on his own wits and abilities to win girls while ye wuchen didnt even if you ignore that he influenced the hua girl that was engaged to the genius son of his enemy clan he didnt really need to rape the girl right (call me two faced or a hypocrite but i dont think that this rape can be compared to how yun che does things at least yun che was forced by circumstances even if he enjoyed it) if ye wuchen really wanted to drive his opponent made with jealousy there were other ways to do it especially after confirming the girl's resolve(dont know anything about after that since i dropped heavenly star at the chapter violated the girl

 

i think the reaction of what is HS tells you what most people think when you ask which is better. i started heavenly star and i still had no clue what you meant by HS without reading the tag. I dropped it really early on it wasn't great.