https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Hope_Plus_One Link to probably the only setup I know, which had both a cop and a doc together without the game becoming town-sided... It's a fun one btw
It was evil, sincerely. Pure evil and sadism. We could kill the Sherif but we thought we could not due to role-switching.
Yeah, I was really surprised by the night-kill... you got really lucky with it though I could have gotten him lynched for you you didn't even need to kill him Though fossil did check him, so it turned out good
Sherrif was the only role that revealed on death and didn't move it was so hard not laughing when Fossil kept on talking about how he wanted to move it.
Aye aye. It was basically a gamble, at that moment, I was like : "Yup, no way to win, might as well do that, then they will lynch the neutral... if Fossil didn't check me. Oh well, I will prolly get checked later on." And then... Ginger happened. But frankly, it was either killing you, Ginger or Scattered. The lynch was between me & Scattered, one of us will obviously be checked. So killing Scattered was kinda obvious IMO.
I don't feel anything about this game. I basically joined at the end of it. I just coin toss who wins.
Oh wait, you meant, you were surprised by me killing Ginger? Fossil has the medic, then, who is left? The Ginger or SoL.
And tbh I noticed you were a PR D1... i even crumbed to it d1 and started to defend you in an avoidant way when zone attacked you for sth And then I explained it D2 when you claimed You would have been dead N1 if I were mafia lol There's no way I would have let you live So I feel I might have really decreased everyone's suspicions on me if I just posted But tbh I really feel it's better that the mafia won So dw about it
You shouldn't have known that he had a doc ability... (Or did I miss a claim?) Anyway, with the info you had fossil would have been the right choice imo Though it would have led to your loss So you made a good decision
Oh. Then you quoted the wrong post lol. Anyway... As for why Scattered. If I wanted to resume it: A gamble Fossil... would pass his role, so, useless. (he revealed it wasn't passable after Scattered's kill) So, it was : Rotte, Ginger & Scattered who could possibly get the role. The sheriff is gonna investigate either me or Scattered. If it's me, no matter who I lynch, it doesn't matter. If it's Scattered... Then, let's say I choose not to lynch Scattered: Ginger & Rotte are left. (And Fossil, but it's useless, while he might be confirmed town.) Well. Ginger has been doubting you and has been shading me for some reasons(side note, I never was replied when I said it and was basically ignored! D: ), he must have been thinking we were both Mafia. Fossil... well, he will not have the Sheriff role but he is confirmed town (remember, I don't know that the Sheriff wasn't a passable role), I have then a chance on 3 to kill the Sheriff. (Rotte, Ginger & Scattered: 33%. Might be worth it.) And you... while you are troublesome since you are an experienced player... You listened to my comments I guess? And thought I was town-like for a short moment. Well, you were also doubting Scattered but slowly changed opinion... it would have been logical to lynch you but... ... why didn't I lynch you actually? Well, I suppose the gamble was much more appealing. Side note, most of the time, I participate when people question me, I rarely take the initiative. Might be because I had my first game as a neutral. Which explains why my messages are... irregular? I guess? I play the same no matter what is my affiliation(I think?). Then, what would happen if I lynch Scattered: Well, I kill the one who is persuaded of me being Mafia. First, that's a good point. It was either or him for the next lynch... or so I thought. If I kill him, wouldn't I be immediately lynch? Unless they think the mafia try to frame it on me. Mmm, Scattered had tensions with Ginger and you if I remember well. Fossil thought I wouldn't be Mafia and that I was townie (after his death, so the "mafia tried to frame it on me.", that's probably what he thought, since I wouldn't kill the only one that might protect me from a lynch.) And soem stuff like that I basically forgot~
Waaait, I thought that Fossil could get back his role, so actually, it was 25% of chance to kick the good one, and I was choosing among 75%.