You need to read/watch/hear some SCP stories to know what makes it creepy XD Spoiler: Here is a little sample
It depends on the scp in question (some are creepy, some are weird, some are sad, etc...), so far, at least to me and amongst the ones I know, two SCP sound creepy to me, they are SCP-1128 and SCP-303 XD
Que….? The fact that while probably impossible, they might exist irl. I am not ready for that much creepiness irl.
creepy because they use real life scenarios But it easily falls apart And a little disgusting sometimes Why is there no I don’t like it option in the poll
They're really interesting but I only every read them when I'm excessively bored or something of that sort
The worst and only one I read was where the entire story revolved around the kitchen having a carpeted floor, that was- *shudders*