Discussion Xianxia vs Game elements

Honestly they are mostly the same thing

Game elements use "numbers" (level, exp, percentages)
Xian Xia use "titles" (cultivation ranks, enlightenment, skill qualities)

its the exact same thing, just with words rather than numbers.

Game element "drop items" Xian Xia monsters "Guard items" or can be "Harvested" this is why its so easy to make games out of xian xia novels, they are already in the proper format, just without numbers attached.

 

I like both theme but for me this depend on Main character , world setting and story development that author create

 

reincarnation to the game world xianxia

 

gaming - few but the good ones are great
xianxia - a lot that are good, but not the greatest

 

I don't know why, but the fights in novels based on game elements tend to get really monotonous, while fights in xianxia tend to keep me hooked a little more.