How to Make Better Rating System?

this is also a good suggestion

yeah, i agree.. the translator should write the review about the novel after it is uploaded...

Hmm,, i think u misunderstand my thread... this is not about me or your way of reading and judging a novel, but about how to make a better rating system for general readers....



And i think some people who comment in this thread are too pessimisitic and acquiesce...

 

Yeah, there are couple of people who go to the extremes like either too good or too bad

 

i know, it's just what i'm trying to say is, sure, the rating system is flawed, you can never have an opinion based system be perfect, but thats why i think instead of looking at the rating, be it negative or positive, i think you should look at the reasons why it's negative or positive, since it differs from person to person. 1 reviewers negative might be another ones positive and vice versa, while they might both be YOUR negative or positive, so as long as you only pay atention to long reviews, and take the time reading what might be the problem or the good thing about the story, and then judge it yourselvf, i don't think the system needs changing

 

thats an entirely different thing though isn't it? You can keep track of the people who one star novels translated by certain groups, but how do we keep track of how many chapters of a novel people read?

 

Well, I honestly think it's kinda impossible to make it better... It works like this tbh.

I personally don't care one bit about ratings, but I guess some people do care...

Forcing people to write reviews wouldn't work, it would just overload Tony (he reads all reviews) and would just make the number of reviews bigger... Not necessarily better, since the well thought reviews would be written even if the person wasn't forced to.

Rating based on different aspects could maybe work? Though some people always say translation quality and release speed for some reason, even if the guidelines already say they shouldn't talk about those... >.>

Oh well, I doubt there will be any change to the system tbh, I don't see any as a direct improvement, and Tony probably won't do any change if it's not an assured improvement.

 

kinda late when some people go out of their way to put 1 stars on quidan stuff because it quidan, or 1 stars on adult writings because they dont like adult stuff.

 

Perhaps a separate ratings based ones that left behind a review.

 

by threat da rater~
wrong rate and your head will fly to andromeda~

it back to da user~ hmm da community more precisely~

 

One major point no one has mentioned is nu has a bit over 3000 novels. What's gonna happen to the previous ratings. There'll be trolling and biased ratings to the not so popular series.

 

Rating is is important for me. Because whenever we search using genre or rating base on popularity is very common thing to do.
Im sure many nufer pick novels base on watch rating popularity weekly or montly as parameter to pick novels.
Im sure many newbies done that.

 

Nu could add a a progress system Which allows users to rate segments of the Novel. Eg 5 star for the first chapter 1-10, 3 stars from 10-20. The novel have upto 5 segments and they grow the the translation if the translation has 100 chapters then the segment are spit into 20 each. If some one rates the novel twice in the section keep the newest update. You would need to allow rerating and it would need to be connected to the read list fuction