It was obvious once I saw how Tilgarial reacted to Blitz's questions, but Tilgarial is wrong. The game shouldn't be over yet. Mafia still has to choose who between us will live. Otherwise we might throw the game and vote him.
Wrong person, same conclusion. @Blitz, choose who will live between @Evil_Ginger and me, or else we will kill you.
Affiliation: Neutral Role: Rival Abilities: None Wincondition: Somewhere out there, is another Rival. Kill them before either mafia or town loses. Probably would have been better to couple this with a bigger game, I think. The 5 player made it too small, so it ended too quickly. Maybe an amendement as to what zone suggests would make sense
Hmmmm If we switch that with the version that joins either mafia or town if they werent involved with the others death(depending on who killed 'em), and add another player to standard game, it wouldnt be much of a deviation from standard bot game.
...wait, it doesn't matter. Neut wincon is "kill before either side loses" and town's wincon is "survive". Both towns are dead, so... both neuts lost. Meaning that it really is a mafia-only win. ...well, that's a shame then.
Welp. Apparently it is this quick; 1 cycle with less than 24 hours. Dunno about this, but he won though.
That'd mean that both me and Ginger would've lost regardless, since mafia lost their wincon. (Unless their wincon doesn't require them to survive.)
would it make sense to give those a cop-like ability? either an affiliation tester, or a simple rival/no rival info
Yes it would. Not that it mattered in a 5-er though, since a simple mislynch + town nightkill will still give a loss for both neutrals. In our case, it might've been better to give both neuts 1 name of someone who isn't the rival.
Hm? No? I just wanted to vote someone. I was thinking about voting Blitz originally, but I’m already bullying him in the KR thread.
You were just unfortunate. You could've attacked me to make it more interesting, but I didn't expect Tilgarial to actually end the day faster through majority instead of waiting for everyone to respond. @Tilgarial, don't do that next time. You're somewhat recreating Rokugan FM, in that some people didn't have the chance to speak.